Café Carmellini
Eats · Manhattan, New York, United States
Entry № 085_NEW · Verified Apr 2026
★ 4.5 (477)
01 / 01Scroll to browse · 1 photograph
Located inside
destination.about
Nestled in the heart of New York City at 250 5th Ave, Café Carmellini invites you to experience a delightful fusion of culinary craftsmanship and sophistication. With a stellar rating of 4.5 stars from over 400 reviews, this café stands out not just for its exquisite dishes but also for the warm hospitality that greets every guest. Open daily from early morning to late evening, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a leisurely brunch, a refined lunch, or an indulgent dinner. Upon entering, you’re embraced by an atmosphere that echoes the charm of both classic New York and Parisian cafés. The meticulous decor enhances the dining experience, making it a feast for the eyes as well as the palate. Reviewers rave about the culinary offerings, with highlights including the Squab en Croûte, praised for its tender, flavorful meat enveloped in a perfectly crisp pastry, and the playful Duck Duck Duck tortellini that showcases the kitchen’s technical precision. Each dish is carefully curated to tantalize your taste buds, ensuring that every meal feels like a special occasion. The service at Café Carmellini is another point of distinction, with guests noting the attentive staff who treat diners like royalty. Angel, the head server, has received particular acclaim for his exceptional hospitality and insightful recommendations. The café's commitment to a seamless dining experience occasionally experiences minor lapses, but the overall ambiance and food quality more than compensate. Whether you’re enjoying a masterfully crafted cocktail at the portrait bar or indulging in the decadent sticky toffee pudding, a visit to Café Carmellini promises to be a memorable highlight of your New York adventure.
Why Café Carmellini stands out
Café Carmellini is a eats in New York, rated ★ 4.5 across 477 reviews. Nestled in the heart of New York City at 250 5th Ave, Café Carmellini invites you to experience a delightful fusion of culinary craftsmanship and sophistication
City
New York
Category
Eats
Neighborhood
Manhattan
Rating
★ 4.5 (477)
Design story
Style
neoclassical
Architecture & Design
Style
neoclassical
Analyzing sentiment...
Extracting topics...
“If you are looking for a venue that screams "New York Glamour," Café Carmellini in the Fifth Avenue Hotel is a top-tier contender. It is a stunning, high-energy space that feels like a modern tribute to the Gilded Age, complete with sculptu…”
— Stéphane Heckel, 3 weeks ago
Editors’ notes
“Love the elegant and grand space - I felt a bit theater vibe. The service was the top notch, attentive, warm and welcoming. We started with crab & meyer lemon mille feuille and finished with chocolate & pear mille feuille. The textures of the mille feuille were different, but both were delivered well. While the risotto…”
— Doraemon
“went for lunch. food was well plated and served on such beautiful plates, but it was missing flavor. my black bass was not seasoned or spiced at all and the sauce it came with did not combine with the filet at all. (they did not play together) however, the mashed potatoes it came with was damn good. their sourdoug…”
— DH K
“Came for our wedding anniversary and had a wonderful experience. Service was the highlight as they made the experience superb. Foodwise the chocolate dessert was my favorite as well as the bavette where the layered fried potatoe was nice. Chicken was feally well cooked and the peppers on the side where even better than…”
— Daniel GOMEZ HARO
“Cafe Carmellini is a wonderful experience, their interior is captivating with every seat in the house being a nice one from booth to balcony seat. Staff was fantastic, very friendly and accommodating to a soft time crunch for a Knicks game. Their small menu has many standouts, starting with the carpaccio which is eleva…”
— Joshua Fields